Jets fans don’t have a consensus quarterback choice

The Jets 2026 quarterback situation is up in the air as we approach free agency. The only two quarterbacks the team has under contract for next season, Justin Fields and Brady Cook, were among the least effective signal callers in the league in 2025. Unfortunately, the list of options available in free agency and on the trade market is full of uninspiring names. There also isn’t a top tier quarterback prospect after Fernando Mendoza, who is a lock to be selected first overall by the Raiders.

What should the Jets do at quarterback then? We asked Jets fans in this week’s SB Nation Reacts survey. The votes revealed no consensus in the fanbase.

The list provided some of the most discussed options potentially available to the Jets. Not one of the quarterbacks listed registered even one quarter of the vote. The option for none of these quarterbacks received the most votes.

Unfortunately that might be the story of the Jets’ offseason quarterback options. It is way easier to be against all of these options than for any of them. If there is an obvious solution, I’m not sure whom it is.