On the Anfield Index Media Matters podcast, Lynch argued the backlash was disproportionate. He noted that Liverpool is the most successful club in history, which naturally places earlier greats high in rankings. Lynch also highlighted Carragher's own credentials, citing him as the club's second most capped player and a European Cup winner.
Lynch criticized the personal attacks directed at the former player and emphasized that while Salah is exceptional, historical rankings often feature fine margins. The pundit concluded that the social media reaction was blown out of proportion and lacked necessary respect for Carragher's career achievements.